|
hat
brand and SPF of sunscreen absorbs the most UVA and UVB rays? If we were
to test what brand and SPF of sunscreen absorbs the most UVA and UVB
rays, we figured that the Coppertone Sport with both SPF 15 and 30 would
be the brand that would prove to be the best.
Our hypothesis was
wrong. When reading our results it was difficult to decide which
sunscreen was the most absorbent, but we were very sure that it was not
the Coppertone Sport. Brands like the Safeway SPF 15 sunscreen absorbed
the most at 310nm but when the wavelength increased, absorbency dropped,
therefore showing that it is only very effective against UVB rays. The
Loréal Ombrelle sunscreen dropped a lot, just like Safeway brand, but it
dropped in different places. We were most impressed with Fruit of the
Earth sunscreen which had about equal absorption of UVA and UVB rays and
was consistent all the way across the board.
Our results showed
us that there is something very wrong with the SPF labels on sunscreen.
You’ll notice on our graphs, that the two best absorbents against 310nm
(UVB rays) were really SPF 15. After being the top here, they didn’t
drop down far below the best for the following nm either. Below these
results we noticed that the very worst results were from a SPF 30
sunscreen, this was the Hawaiian Tropic. So what does that tell us?
Quite possibly that SPF doesn’t mean as much as we think it does. Maybe
it means the companies are lying to us. Maybe it means we tested bad
product. Maybe it shows our testing was false. Maybe it shows that every
hundredth of a gram had to be dissolved in order for the sunscreen to
work 100%. Either way though, SPF appeared to be much less of predictor
than people are lead to believe.
Though after hearing
the information given, I’m sure it is very easy to side with the
companies and say that our testing was just not executed properly and we
have bad results. I assure you, this is not true. In doing our
experiment we were extremely careful to control every aspect. Many tests
were done several times just to be sure they were true, and lastly each
and every sample was treated exactly the same during all parts of the
experiment. Our testing was done thoroughly and with little error and
room for doubt.
|